Would you murder one innocent to save two?
Back-
A runaway train with two passengers speeds toward a bridge over a deep canyon. The bridge is destroyed, and if the train continues on its course then the two passengers will die. You have the chance to throw the switch and divert the train onto a different track where a single man is working on the rails. If you choose to divert the train then you will murder the worker, but the two passengers will survive. If you choose not to intervene then worker will live, but the passengers will die. There are no other options. What do you do?
-
What are the two passangers? Gender, age, and the age of the worker.
-
Why does gender matter? Sexist!
-
You didn't explain who the passengers are. But anyways, saving two lives is better than one.
-
You didn't explain who the passengers are. But anyways, saving two lives is better than one.
Not neccesarily true. By killing that one man you may have ruined a family and caused htem to all die off. -
Ok. I KNOW THIS ONE!! I DID IT ONCE BEFORE!
Ok. You pull out a sniper and shoot the worker then jump out of the train letting it fall off the cliffs.
Thus I get exp for
1. Killing the gremlin trying to destroy the railroad.
2. Killing the zombies in the train.
3. Being epic as I do a barrel roll out of the train.
-
So, um, the fellow cannot hear you yelling to get out of the way? Or notice there is a huge noisy train coming his way?
Um... -
So, um, the fellow cannot hear you yelling to get out of the way? Or notice there is a huge noisy train coming his way?
HES A GREMLIN FOOL! HE DOSENT CARE HE WANTS YOU ALL TO DIE!!!!
Um...
-
What are the two passangers? Gender, age, and the age of the worker.
Not really relevant to the core question.So, um, the fellow cannot hear you yelling to get out of the way? Or notice there is a huge noisy train coming his way?
That's not the point.
Um... -
If it is a runaway train I wouldn't do anything. There is no saying it won't hit another train.
I would let them die. They made the choice to get on a train and it was bad luck. I would not endanger more people (willingly kill another) to possibly save the person. It would have to be 100% chance that only one would die. -
Just say the worker/Gremlin is Deaf.What are the two passangers? Gender, age, and the age of the worker.
Not really relevant to the core question.So, um, the fellow cannot hear you yelling to get out of the way? Or notice there is a huge noisy train coming his way?
That's not the point.
Um... -
is their a vote to get yourself out of the train to keep yourself saved.
i mean saving either one will result in you killing someone then why not let the train run the worker over since it will not go off the broken bridge. -
I literally have a headache that I didn't have before I read this.